Have you decided yet? we had our first CD fridge in our previous home when we remodeled. It was a side by side with ice in the door. I miss that fridge! We also had a beverage fridge in the kitchen and an overflow fridge in the basement. In our new home we gave a GE Cafe (do they still make those?) CD french door with ice in the door. Also have a beverage fridge and overflow fridge in the basement. Its 14 years old and still going strong.

No issues with the ice/water in the door. If I had to replace, I would consider the fisher paykel integrated fridge freezer.

If you’re thinking about an FP, check your local area for competent repair people who have the parts.

@Anne Duke, I checked them out, but i don't think they're in our budget.