Like the overall feel of the detail, NOT the color. It’s kind of hard to imagine without that strong color, but overall this one and the other pic you posted today, seem a little too formal for our taste. Kay and I prefer more of the look that we showed you yesterday. I know you said it looked too “cottagey”, but we like that more comfortable/informal look. I am definitely not thinking formal, and I agree that dark shiny gives it that feel, I am more looking at how the cabinets are constructed.